Did Peanuts Coin a Popular Quote About Love and Chocolate? - CBR

Summary

• Peanuts fans feel a personal connection to the characters
• Misattributions are common, including the famous love and chocolate quote often falsely attributed to Charles Schulz and Peanuts characters.
• Derrick Bang, a Peanuts expert, confirmed that Schulz never made or wrote the popular quote attributed to him or any Peanuts characters.

Welcome to the 933rd installment of Comic Book Legends Revealed, a column where we examine three comic book myths, rumors and legends and confirm or debunk them. In the second legend of this all-Peanuts installment, learn whether a famous quote involving love and chocolate has been incorrectly attributed to Charles Schulz and/or his comic strip, Peanuts.

In the brilliant Michael Barrier interview with Charles Schulz that I've quoted a few times now, Schulz discussed how big the Peanuts characters had become as licensed characters (used in commercials and cartoons and stuff like that), and he nicely explained how the most famous comic characters tend to become more than just "yours" after a while:

Now, there are some people who are against licensing, and in a way, I suppose it should be flattering. They have become fond of your work, and they clutch it to themselves very selfishly. They want it to be theirs. They have discovered this new comic strip and they want to talk about it with their friends, and all of a sudden it becomes popular. It's like hearing a new singer for the first time, and you think she's just wonderful, and before you know it she's got four or five hit records and everybody in the country is talking about her. You've lost her-she's not yours any more. You've lost your discovery, and I suppose this is one of the things that people don't like. But we live in a culture where this is almost taken for granted. Everybody is involved in licensing. If Bill Cosby can sell chocolate pudding and all of the other things that he sells, and Willie Mays can sell things with his picture, and all the movie actors, everybody does it, why should I say, "No, I'm too good for this sort of thing"? Because it's not all mine anyway. As I said back at the beginning, this is not a pure art form by any means, it's a commercial product, and I've always said, "How can a commercial product be accused of turning commercial?" It doesn't make sense. As I've also said, I've been very careful about all the things that we've done. Perhaps we've made some mistakes, but I don't think we've ever turned out anything that was offensive, and I know I've never drawn anything that was offensive. Our television cartoons are as inoffensive as we can make them, without being sugary sweet and dumb. All I can say is that I've just done the best that I can, that's all.

While Schulz is more specifically talking about licensing, it speaks, also, to the idea that when a character becomes REALLY famous, their creators really don't have "ownership" over them, at least not when it comes to the public's imagination. It sort of ties to something I wrote recently about headcanon. You're obviously always owed your personal take on a character, even if you have no direct control over the character, no one else can tell you what to THINK about the character.

And so Snoopy, Charlie Brown, and the rest of the Peanuts gang have long entered into the sort of public consciousness (just not the public domain, of course), and so people really feel like they KNOW them, and BECAUSE they know them, they like to quote them a lot...like, a LOT. Even if the quotes might not belong to them...

Related

Why Did Hasbro First Not Allow Marvel to Use This Iconic Transformers Cover?

In the latest Comic Book Legends Revealed, learn why Hasbro objected to the most iconic Transformers comic book cover of all-time

What is the famous quote about love and chocolate that is credited to Charles Schulz?

I just did a cursory look of the internet for this phrase related to Peanuts, and, well, great googley moogley, it is WIDESPREAD. I picked just four almost at random (my father hates the way people use the word "random," as people almost never use it correctly, as if you use any sort of control over your choices, you are inherently NOT doing it at random. So I just throw in qualifiers like "almost at random" to mollify the voice in my head of my dad moaning about me using "random" incorrectly)....

As you can see, the public really loves this quote, "All you need is love ... but a little chocolate now and then doesn't hurt," and it loves to attribute it to Charles Schulz in general, or Peanuts in specific (sometimes even specific characters WITHIN Peanuts, even Lucy Van Pelt).

We see this come up frequently with cool quotes, where Mark Twain gets credited for almost every old witty line. And Jack Kirby often gets credited for cool comic book innovations, whether he did them or not, as Twain and Kirby are both famous, beloved figures, who we tend to gravitate to when we're talking about moments and quotes that we don't recall specifically. The same goes for Schulz.

Related

When Did They Establish That Magneto Could Touch Rogue in the X-Men Comics?

In the latest Comic Book Legends Revealed, discover whether the X-Men comics ever established that Magneto was immune to Rogue's powers

Did Charles Schulz (or any Peanuts character) say the love and chocolate quote?

The great Peanuts expert, Derrick Bang (who I've cited a few times in the past for Peanuts legends), explained that the quote is NOT from Schulz or Peanuts. He noted,

The quote above, which has become incredibly pervasive -- turning up on samplers, posters and countless versions of desktop art -- most frequently is attributed to Schulz, and sometimes to Lucy. Such claims notwithstanding, Schulz never said any such thing, nor did any character in any Peanuts strip say anything remotely approaching this phrase. (On top of which, Lucy is the last person who'd ever say something so sickly-sweet.)

But hey, it FEELS real to people!

Thanks so much to Derrick for the information (and to Michael Barrier for the Schulz quote).

Check out a TV Legends Revealed

In the latest TV Legends Revealed - What early Jennifer Aniston TV series killed off the cast members of the series in every episode?

Be sure to check out my Entertainment Legends Revealed for more urban legends about the world of film and TV. Plus, Pop Culture References also has some brand-new Entertainment and Sports Legends Revealeds!

Feel free to send suggestions for future comic legends to me at either cronb01@aol.com or brianc@cbr.com.

Adblock test (Why?)

https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiR2h0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNici5jb20vcGVhbnV0cy1zbm9vcHktY2hhcmxlcy1zY2h1bHotbG92ZS1jaG9jb2xhdGUtcXVvdGUv0gEA?oc=5

2024-05-27 13:08:42Z

Bagikan Berita Ini